Simon's Legal Resources

(Ontario/Canada)

HOME / About / Democracy, Law and Duty / Testimonials / Essays / Link Policy / Help! / Opinion Intake / Conditions of Use

TOPICS


Private International Law (PRIL) - Administrative

. Toronto Star Newspapers Limited v. OpenAI, Inc. [tort]

In Toronto Star Newspapers Limited v. OpenAI, Inc. (Ont CA, 2026) the Ontario Court of Appeal considers the 'real and substantial connection' test to determine a court's geographical jurisdiction over a proceeding, here citing exceptions to this Van Breda doctrine in administrative proceedings:
[25] On the first step of this test, the court is presumptively entitled to assume jurisdiction over a dispute involving a tort if there is good arguable case supporting at least one of an open list of factors: (i) the defendant is domiciled or resident in the province; (ii) the defendant carries on business in the province; (iii) the tort was committed in the province; or (iv) a contract connected with the dispute was made in the province: Van Breda, at para. 90. If a plaintiff shows a good arguable case that a presumptive connecting factor exists, a defendant may still, on the second stage of the test, rebut the presumption by demonstrating that there is no real relationship between the dispute and the forum – that there is no “real and substantial connection”: Van Breda, at para. 97. That is, that despite the existence of the presumed connection, the connection is not sufficiently strong: Sinclair v. Venezia Turismo, 2025 SCC 27, 505 D.L.R. (4th) 451, at para. 50.

....

[30] Although courts have declined to apply Van Breda in some situations, this has occurred in the regulatory enforcement context in relation to the jurisdictional limits of administrative agencies: see Sharp v. Autorité des marchés financiers, 2023 SCC 29, 487 D.L.R. (4th) 467, at para. 123; Clearview AI Inc. v. British Columbia (Information and Privacy Commissioner), 2026 BCCA 67, at para. 24, leave to appeal to S.C.C. requested, 42312. In contrast, the Copyright Act establishes rights through the creation of statutory causes of action for copyright infringement enforceable in private law: see Pourshian, at para. 43. Such rights are justiciable by courts of inherent jurisdiction unless otherwise displaced by legislation, and the appellants have not identified any authorities to the contrary.

....

[37] The appellants rely heavily on the fact that they did not have a physical presence within Ontario. However, the authorities cited in support of a proposition that physical presence is required do not assist. Though the appellants seek support from cases involving presence-based jurisdiction, the standard for assumed jurisdiction, as acknowledged in H.M.B. Holdings Ltd. v. Antigua and Barbuda, 2021 SCC 44, [2021] 3 S.C.R. 285, at para. 45, may be distinct from and lower than that required for carrying on business under the traditional presence-based jurisdiction.

....

[40] For present purposes, it is sufficient to note that the motion judge did not err in her reliance on Equustek Solutions Inc. v. Google Inc., 2015 BCCA 265, 386 D.L.R. (4th) 224, aff’d 2017 SCC 34, [2017] 1 S.C.R. 824, in finding that there was a good arguable case that the appellants carried on business in Ontario for the context of assumed jurisdiction, even without a physical presence.

....

[44] In any event, Ontario courts may assume jurisdiction so long as one of the presumptive connecting factors are shown: Van Breda, at para. 80; Bridging Finance Inc. v. Sharpe, 2026 ONCA 432, at para. 25. Here, there are three. Thus, even had the appellants been successful on appeal with regard to the wrongdoing arising from the copyright infringement on appeal, it would not have been dispositive.

....

[50] On the second step of the Van Breda analysis, a defendant bears the onus of rebutting the strength of the connection established in the first step: Sinclair, at para. 50. ....



CC0

Unless authorship is otherwise stated or obvious from the context, all
written materials in this website were created by Simon Shields, who
waives all of his copyright and related or neighboring rights to this
Isthatlegal.ca webpage. Note in particular that this waiver only applies to
Simon's material, as copyright in statutory/regulatory materials and
case extracts were never his to give away.




Last modified: 16-11-26
By: admin