Simon's Legal Resources

(Ontario/Canada)

HOME / About / Democracy, Law and Duty / Testimonials / Essays / Link Policy / Help! / Opinion Intake / Conditions of Use

TOPICS


Courts - Inherent and Plenary Powers (3)

. Canada (Attorney General) v. Almrei

In Canada (Attorney General) v. Almrei (Fed CA, 2026) the Federal Court of Appeal allowed a Crown appeal, this regarding whether "section 18.1 [SS: 'Prohibition on disclosure' (of human national security sources)] of the CSIS Act is a complete statutory code" or whether the court's plenary powers provide for additional litigation disclosure:
[33] I accept that the designated judge, as a member of the Federal Court, possesses plenary powers that are analogous to the inherent powers of a provincial superior court of record, and that absent explicit statutory jurisdiction, the Federal Court’s plenary powers can be used to redress abuses of its own process or to control the integrity of its own processes (744185 Ontario Inc. v. Canada, 2020 FCA 1 at para. 28, citing Canada (Human Rights Commission) v. Canadian Liberty Net, 1998 CanLII 818 (SCC), [1998] 1 S.C.R. 626 at paras. 35-38 and Canada (National Revenue) v. RBC Life Insurance Company, 2013 FCA 50 at paras. 34-36; see also Canada (Attorney General) v. Hutton, 2023 FCA 45 at para. 16; Lee v. Canada (Correctional Service), 2017 FCA 228 at paras. 7-8, 12; Canadian Security Intelligence Act (CA)(Re), 2020 FC 616 at paras. 205-206 (Re CSIS Act, 2020 FC 616) (appeal allowed in part in 2021 FCA 92).

[34] That said, the Federal Court’s plenary powers cannot be relied upon to disregard the statutory scheme chosen by Parliament. Where the information before the designated judge is captured by section 18.1 of the CSIS Act, the plenary powers of the designated judge are displaced and the information must be dealt with in accordance with the scheme established under that provision.

[35] The need for caution in resorting to the exercise of plenary powers was highlighted by the Supreme Court of Canada in Endean v. British Columbia, 2016 SCC 42. There, the Court stated that "“given the broad and loosely defined nature of [the inherent powers of superior courts], they should be ‘exercised sparingly and with caution’… [and that it] follows that courts should first determine the scope of express grants of statutory powers before dipping into this important but murky pool of residual authority that forms their inherent jurisdiction”" (at para. 24).

....

[60] As this Court noted in Hutton, "“[plenary] powers are meant to assist the Court in managing its own proceedings, such as to summarily dismiss, of its own motion, proceedings that are doomed to fail or are an abuse of the process of the Court”", but "“were never intended to provide a party before the Court with a remedy that is not legally available”" (at para. 16).
. His Majesty the King in right of Ontario v. Dell

In His Majesty the King in right of Ontario v. Dell (Div Court, 2023) the Divisional Court considered whether the court could look to it's 'inherent jurisdiction' to justify orders which were issued prior to a statutory 'leave to sue' requirement (it couldn't):
(2) Inherent Jurisdiction

[55] All agree that the scope of inherent jurisdiction does not extend to making orders that contravene a statute. The court may exercise its inherent jurisdiction even in respect of matters that are regulated by statute, “so long as the court can do so without contravening any statutory provision”: R. v. Caron, 2011 SCC 5, at para. 32 (emphasis in Caron); Stephen Francis Podgurski (Re), 2020 ONSC 2552, at para. 69.

[56] It is therefore unnecessary to address this issue. The Superior Court’s inherent jurisdiction cannot be used to contravene the automatic stay in s. 17 of the Act.
. Turmel v. Canada (Attorney General)

In Turmel v. Canada (Attorney General) (Fed CA, 2023) the Federal Court of Appeal considered (and dismissed) an appeal from a frivolous litigant declaration order [under s.40 FCA], here with supplementary terms regarding outstanding cost orders and "aiding or abetting others to initiate proceedings before that Court". In this quote the court endorses for this purpose a reliance on the 'plenary jurisdiction' of the statutory (not s.96 constitutional) Federal Court of Appeal:
[12] Respecting the additional measures imposed on the appellant, the Application Judge correctly pointed out that the Federal Court has “plenary jurisdiction to impose additional requirements as may be necessary to prevent abuses of process” and that some litigants may require different measures and restrictions, including safeguards to “discourage them from finding other ways to continue their vexatious conduct” (Decision at paras. 49–50).



CC0

Unless authorship is otherwise stated or obvious from the context, all
written materials in this website were created by Simon Shields, who
waives all of his copyright and related or neighboring rights to this
Isthatlegal.ca webpage. Note in particular that this waiver only applies to
Simon's material, as copyright in statutory/regulatory materials and
case extracts were never his to give away.




Last modified: 08-10-26
By: admin