Rarotonga, 2010

Simon's Megalomaniacal Legal Resources

(Ontario/Canada)

EVIDENCE | ADMINISTRATIVE LAW | SPPA / Fairness (Administrative)
SMALL CLAIMS / CIVIL LITIGATION / CIVIL APPEALS / JUDICIAL REVIEW / Something Big

Home / About / Democracy, Law and Duty / Testimonials / Conditions of Use

Civil and Administrative
Litigation Opinions
for Self-Reppers


TOPICS

(What's a Topic?)


Class Proceeding - Subjects Table of Contents (A-C)




Glossary (Class Proceeding)



GENERAL

General
Class Proceeding Cases - General
Class Proceeding Cases (Ont) - General
Class Proceeding Cases (Fed) - General

Definitions
CPA (Ont) s.1(1) Definitions ["court"]
CPA (Ont) s.1(1) Definitions ["defendant"]
CPA (Ont) s.1(1) Definitions ["Minister"]
CPA (Ont) s.1(1) Definitions ["plaintiff"]
CPA (Ont) s.1(2) "Proceeding", Meaning
CPA (Ont) s.1(3) "Representative Party", Meaning



APPEALS


Ontario

General
Class Proceeding Cases (Ont) - Appeal - Standard of Review (SOR)

Remedies
Class Proceeding Cases (Ont) - Appeal -Remedies

Appeal Route
Class Proceeding Cases (Ont) - Appeal - Appeal Route
Ontario Court of Appeal
CPA (Ont) s.30(1-2,4) Appeals to CA from Certification Orders; Restrictions on Amendment of Pleadings
CPA (Ont) s.30(3,5) Appeals to CA from Common Issue Judgments and Non-Individual Remedy Orders

Divisional Court
CPA (Ont) s.30(6-8) Appeals to Divisional Court from Individual Issue Orders Where Equal to or Above Small Claims Monetary Limit
CPA (Ont) s.30(9-11) Appeals (with Leave from the Superior Court) to Divisional Court from Individual Issue Orders Under Small Claims Monetary Limit
RCP (Ont) R.12.06(1-5) Leave to Appeal to the Divisional Court

Federal

Class Proceeding Cases (Fed) - Appeal - Standard of Review (SOR)

FCR (fed) s.334.31(1-2) Appeals re Individual Questions



APPLICATION, LEGAL

As used here, the term 'application' means when a particular body of written law applies to a recognized procedure (eg. "the general rules of court apply to class proceedings") or parties (eg. "the general rules of court apply to class representatives").


Ontario
CPA (Ont) s.35 RCP Application to the CPA Proceedings
CPA (Ont) s.37 CPA Non-Application to Various Representative Proceedings [# Civil Litigation]

CPA (Ont) s.36 CPA applies to the Crown


Federal
FCR (fed) s.334.1 Application of Part 5.1 (Class Proceedings) Generally to Federal Proceedings (except s.28 Judicial Reviews)
FCR (fed) s.334.11 General Application of FCR to Class Proceedings



APPLICATION (Type of Proceeding)

A second meaning of the term 'application' refers to a type of legal proceeding with no need to resolve fact disputes (eg. "they started the legal proceeding by application, not action, as they expected no fact disagreements"). Class proceedings can be conducted as either 'actions' (which is more typical) or 'applications', since the term 'proceeding' means both an action or an application [RCP 1.03(1)].

Class Proceeding Cases (Ont) - Application (Proceeding) (there is no case content yet, this is a placeholder)



'CARRIAGE' MOTIONS (RESOLVING COMPETING CLASS PROCEEDINGS)

Ontario

CPA (Ont) s.5(6-8) Resolution of Carriage of Claims Where Competing Other-Provincial Class Proceedings
CPA (Ont) s.13.1(1-8) 'Carriage' Motions (Resolving Competing Class Proceedings)
CPA (Ont) s.34(2,4) Carriage Motions, Different Judges Required Unless Consent



CERTIFICATION

The vast majority of class proceedings involve single representative plaintiffs for each 'class' (sometimes only one) suing a single defendant - typically a large corporation, and these rules are structured with that in mind. It is however possible to have a 'reverse' class proceeding [see that subject below] where multiple representative defendants are sued by a single plaintiff, again typically a large corporation.


Ontario

General
Class Proceeding Cases (Ont) - Certification - General [CPA 5]

Defendant Appointing Representative Plaintiff
CPA (Ont) s.3 Defendant/s Appointing Representative Plaintiff

Certification Criteria
Class Proceeding Cases (Ont) - Certification - 'Disclosing Cause of Action' [CPA 5(1)(a)]
Class Proceeding Cases (Ont) - Certification - 'Identifiable Class' [CPA 5(1)(b)]
Class Proceeding Cases (Ont) - Certification - 'Common Claims and Defences' [CPA 5(1)(c)] (+)
Class Proceeding Cases (Ont) - Certification - 'Preferrable Procedure' [CPA 5(1)(d)]
Class Proceeding Cases (Ont) - Certification - 'Representative Party' [CPA 5(1)(e)]
CPA (Ont) s.5(1) Certification Criteria
CPA (Ont) s.6 Matters Not Barring Certification
CPA (Ont) s.5(1.1) Preferrable Procedure Criteria, Interpretation
CPA (Ont) s.5(2) Common Issues Criteria, Requirements Where Subclass

Notice of Certification (to Class Members)
CPA (Ont) s.17(1-8) Notice of Certification to Class Members; Orders

Certification Orders
Class Proceeding Cases (Ont) - Certification - 'Conditional' Certification
CPA (Ont) s.8(1-2) Contents of Certification Order
RCP (Ont) R.12.05(2) Contents of Certification-related Orders

Effects of Certification
CPA (Ont) s.5(5) Certification No Ruling on Merits

Where Certification Refused
Class Proceeding Cases (Ont) - Proceeding Cases May Continue in Altered Form [CPA s.7(2)]
CPA (Ont) s.7(1) If Certification Refused, Notice to Affected Members or Parties
CPA (Ont) s.7(2) If Certification Refused, Continuation of Proceeding

Amendments/Decertification of Certification Orders
CPA (Ont) s.8(3) Amendment of Certification Order
CPA (Ont) s.10(1-3) Amendment/Decertification of Certification Order where it appears conditions for certification not satisfied


Federal

General
Class Proceeding Cases (Fed) - Certification - General

Certification Criteria
Class Proceeding Cases (Fed) - Certification - 'Disclosing Cause of Action' [FCR 334.16(1)(a)]
Class Proceeding Cases (Fed) - Certification - 'Identifiable Class' [FCR 334.16(1)(b)]
Class Proceeding Cases (Fed) - Certification - 'Common Claims and Defences' [FCR 334.16(1)(c)]
Class Proceeding Cases (Fed) - Certification - 'Preferrable Procedure' [FCR 334.16(1)(d)]
Class Proceeding Cases (Fed) - Certification - 'Representative Party' [FCR 334.16(1)(e)]
FCR (fed) s.334.16(1) Certification Criteria
FCR (fed) s.334.16(2) Preferrable Procedure Criteria, Interpretation
FCR (fed) s.334.16(3) Common Issues Criteria, Requirements Where Subclass

Matters Not Barring Certification
FCR (fed) s.334.18 Matters Not Barring Certification

Defendant Right to Certify
FCR (fed) s.334.13(1-2)Defendant/Respondent Right to Certify; Modifications re Criteria

Certifying Defendants
FCR (fed) s.334.14(2-3) Party May Move for Certification of Representative Defendant/Respondent

Evidence
Class Proceeding Cases (Fed) - Certification - Standard of Proof

Counterclaims
FCR (fed) s.334.14(1,3) Counterclaims Only Proceed Where Plaintiff Certified

Notice of Certification (to Class Members)
FCR (fed) s.334.32(1) Notice of Certification

Where Certification Refused
FCR (fed) s.334.2 Where Certification Refused

Certification Orders
FCR (fed) s.334.17(1-2) Certification Orders
FCR (fed) s.334.19 Amendments/Decertification of Certification Orders



CERTIFICATION MOTIONS


Ontario

Motions Before Certification
CPA (Ont) s.4.1 Some Motions Before Certification (Early resolution of issues)
CPA (Ont) s.5(4) When Adjournments Allowable on Motion for Certification

Standing on Certification Motion
CPA (Ont) s.2(5) Standing of Non-Ontario Plaintiffs When Served with Certification Motion

Evidence on Certification Motion
Class Proceeding Cases (Ont) - Certification - Standard of Proof
CPA (Ont) s.5(3) Evidence of Number of Members of Class

Motion for Certification
CPA (Ont) s.2(2) Motion for Certification
CPA (Ont) s.2(3) Motion for Certification, Affidavit of Registration
RCP (Ont) R.12.02(2) Title of Proceeding

Service of Motion
CPA (Ont) s.2(4) Service of Certification Motion on Non-Ontario Plaintiffs With Similar Proceedings


Federal

Motion for Certification
FCR (fed) s.334.12(1-3) Certification Motion
FCR (fed) s.334.12(4) Originating Document Where s.72 IRPA JR
FCR (fed) s.334.15(1-3) Certification Motion - Delivery and Hearing Dates

Evidence on Certification Motion
FCR (fed) s.334.15(4-5) Certification Motion - Defendant/Respondent's Evidence



COMMENCEMENT OF PROCEEDING

Ontario

CPA (Ont) s.2(1) Representative Plaintiff/Applicant May Commence Proceeding



COMMON ISSUES


Ontario

CPA (Ont) s.1(1) Definitions ["common issues"]
CPA (Ont) s.1.1 Common Issues, Factors to Decide
CPA (Ont) s.27(1-3) Judgment of Common Issues (Liability)


Federal

FCR (fed) s.334.25(1-2) Common Questions, Issue Estoppel Effect
FCR (fed) s.334.33 Notice of Favourable Outcome of Common Questions



CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT

The Consumer Protection Act 2002 (also initialized as the 'CPA') expressly allows 'consumers' to commence class proceedings, and limits the extent to which contractual arbitration is binding after such disputes.

Consumer Protection Act, 2002 s.8(1-4) Class proceedings (1/2)



COSTS, FEES, DISBURSEMENTS AND HONOURARIUMS


Ontario

Costs
Class Proceeding Cases (Ont) - Costs
CPA (Ont) s.31(1-3) Costs
RCP (Ont) R.12.01, 12.04 Costs Where 'Class Proceedings Fund of the Foundation' Provides Support

Fees
Class Proceeding Cases (Ont) - Fees

Fees and Disbursement Agreements
CPA (Ont) s.32(1-6) Fees and Disbursement Agreements; Where Agreement Not Approved
CPA (Ont) s.33(1-9) Fees and Disbursement Agreements for payment only in the event of success
CPA (Ont) s.1(4) "Success", Meaning
CPA (Ont) s.33.1(1-16) Third-Party Funding Agreements

Honourariums
Class Proceeding Cases (Ont) - Honorariums


Federal

Costs
Class Proceeding Cases (Fed) - Costs
FCR (fed) s.334.39(1-2) No Costs Policy and Behavioural Exception; Further Individual Class Exception

Fees
FCR (fed) s.334.4 Judicial Approval for Solicitor Payment of Proceeds Recovered

Disbursements
FCR (fed) s.334.38 Expenses Regarding Notices




Continue to D-Z

CC0

The author has waived all copyright and related or neighboring rights to this Isthatlegal.ca webpage.




Last modified: 11-10-25
By: admin